The Science of Lasting Change: Why We Relapse and How To Build Resilient Habits

The Hidden Challenge of Change

Sarah stared at the green container of [insert greens powder of choice here] sitting untouched on her kitchen counter. Three months ago, starting each day with this health ritual had felt effortless and energizing. Now, like so many well-intentioned habits, it had slowly slipped away. Across town, Mike found himself pouring his usual post-work drink, despite promising himself "just weekends" a month ago.

These aren't stories of failure—they're windows into how our brains navigate change, and why even our most determined efforts sometimes fall short.

Subscribe to our podcast here

Listen to the article here

Why Do We Struggle to Change?

Changing behavior is challenging because it goes against our brain's natural desire for efficiency. Understanding why this happens is the first step toward building lasting habits.

The Brain's Economy: Why Change Is Hard

Your brain operates on what neuroscientists call the "efficiency principle." While comprising only 2% of your body weight, your brain consumes 20% of your daily energy. This creates an interesting paradox: the organ responsible for change is precisely the one most resistant to it. On a side note, think of all the mitochondria and how inefficient metabolism and oxidative stress would have an outsized impact on the lipid rich brain tissue prone to peroxidation. 

The Neural Cost of New Habits

Picture your existing habits as well-traveled highways in your brain. They're efficient, automatic, and energy-saving. New habits are like constructing back roads through dense forest—costly and energy-intensive. Recent neuroimaging studies reveal:

• Familiar patterns use well-myelinated neural pathways, requiring minimal glucose.
• New behaviors demand the formation of new neural connections, consuming significantly more energy.
• Under stress, the brain automatically reverts to established patterns to conserve resources.
• Its not as simple as the 3 week rule for neuroplasticity. It can take months and still we can fall back on older more familiar patterns.

The Role of Neurotransmitters

When you try to build a new habit, neurotransmitters like dopamine play a crucial role. Dopamine is involved in motivation and reward, reinforcing learning and habit formation. It spikes not only when we experience something novel or rewarding but also in anticipation of a reward, which motivates behavior. However, as the novelty decreases over time, the dopamine surge also reduces, making it challenging to sustain new habits without external reinforcements.

Dopamine levels tend to be lower during certain times of the day, particularly in the late afternoon and evening when energy levels drop. Activities such as repetitive tasks without immediate rewards, prolonged work sessions, or stress without adequate breaks can also lower dopamine levels. This is why motivation can be especially challenging during these periods, making it important to plan engaging or rewarding activities earlier in the day when dopamine is naturally higher. Incorporating activities that boost dopamine, like physical exercise, exposure to sunlight, or listening to music, can help maintain motivation and support habit formation.

Here are some behaviors or activities that reduce dopamine levels in the brain:

1. Chronic stress without adequate coping strategies.
2. Prolonged work sessions without breaks.
3. Lack of physical activity.
4. Poor sleep quality or sleep deprivation.
5. Excessive consumption of sugar and processed foods.
6. Overstimulation from excessive screen time or social media use.
7. Substance abuse (e.g., alcohol, drugs).
8. Social isolation and lack of meaningful social interactions.
9. Repetitive, monotonous tasks without any reward or variation.
10. Negative thinking patterns and rumination.

While dopamine often steals the spotlight in discussions about motivation, it's not the only neurotransmitter involved in habit formation. Serotonin and norepinephrine also play significant roles. Serotonin helps stabilize mood and provides a sense of well-being, which can indirectly support the formation of positive habits. Norepinephrine, on the other hand, is associated with focus and alertness, which is crucial when trying to maintain consistency in new habits. Tummo breathing - deep inhalations, breath retention, forceful exhalation triggers the sympathetic nervous system and releases Norepinephrine. Alternatively, yogic breathing patterns such as Pranayam can stimulate the parasympathetic nervous system and calm the body down.

The Two Stories: Morning Rituals and Evening Choices

The Morning Ritual That Slipped Away: Understanding and Preventing Relapse

Meet Sarah, a marketing professional who, like many of us, transitioned to working from home in recent years. After reading about the importance of micronutrients and gut health, she committed to starting each day with a nutrient dense greens powder. For three months, her morning ritual was clockwork: wake up, drink water with aforementioned greens powder, start the day energized.

Then, slowly, things began to unravel.

The Anatomy of a Relapse

Let's break down Sarah's journey to understand why a seemingly simple habit—one that had become routine for three months—gradually slipped away.

The Initial Success (First 3 Months):

• Clear morning structure.
• Prominent environmental cues.
• Immediate rewards (energy, accomplishment).
• Strong motivation.

The Subtle Shifts

Then came the changes, so gradual they were almost imperceptible:

1. Morning Routine Disruption
2. • Later bedtimes led to later wake-ups.
   • Video calls starting earlier.
   • Inbox checking before leaving bed.
   • Consider what these changes do to Cortisol levels and then correlate that with the impact of Cortisol on Dopamine levels.
3. Environmental Changes
4. • The Green container moved to make room for other items.
   • Kitchen became cluttered.
   • Work laptop migrated to kitchen counter.
5. Mental Shifts
6. • Decreased novelty of the ritual.
   • Reduced awareness of benefits. The body felt better and there didn't seem to be a need for the nutrient dense pick-me-up in the morning.
   • Growing decision fatigue. 

Why Work-From-Home Makes Habits Harder

The home office environment presents unique challenges to maintaining habits:

Boundary Blurring

"When your home becomes your office, every room holds the potential for work. Your kitchen counter isn't just for morning rituals anymore—it's also your afternoon meeting spot."

The lack of physical separation between work and personal space affects us in several ways:

1. Time Compression
2. • Morning routines shrink as commute time gets reallocated to work.
   • Boundaries between preparation and production blur.
   • "Just one quick email" syndrome.
3. Decision Overload
4. • Every space serves multiple purposes.
   • Constant context switching.
   • Increased cognitive load.

The Neuroscience of Morning Decisions

Research shows that the first 60 minutes after waking are crucial for setting our daily rhythm. Our brain's decision-making abilities are actually heightened during this period, but this advantage disappears if we immediately expose ourselves to:

• Work-related stress.
• Screen time.
• Decision overload.

Rebuilding the Habit: A Practical Approach

1. The Night-Before Protocol

Create what Behaviorists call an "implementation intention"—a specific plan that removes morning decision-making:

"I will place the green scoop in my designated morning glass before bed, next to the water filter."

2. The Morning Sanctuary

Designate a specific morning-only space in your home:

• Keep it work-free.
• Make it visually appealing, if you must.
• Stock it with only morning ritual items.

3. The Two-Minute Shield

Implement the "two-minute rule" with a twist:

• No screens for the first two minutes of wake time.
• Complete your [insert ritual here] within this window.
• Use this time as a mental buffer between sleep and activity.

Mike's Evening Challenge

Mike's journey with evening drinking illustrates how stress and environment shape our choices:

The Initial Pattern:

Work stress was accumulating, creating a constant background of tension and fatigue. Mike was also in immediate proximity to triggers, such as alcohol at home, which made it harder to resist. Social reinforcement from friends and colleagues who also drank after work contributed to the habit, and the drinking provided temporary relief from the stress of the day.

The Neural Cascade:

1. Peak cortisol levels by day's end, when it should be declining.
2. Maximum decision fatigue, especially if you're in management.
3. Depleted executive function.

Stress and Emotional Regulation

Both Sarah and Mike's experiences also highlight how stress impacts behavior. Chronic stress can weaken our ability to regulate emotions, leading to habitual coping mechanisms like skipping routines or reaching for alcohol. Stress management is a critical component in maintaining positive habits.

The Science of Decision Fatigue

Your capacity for willpower operates like a battery that drains throughout the day. Research shows:

• Decision-making capability decreases by up to 35% after multiple choices.
• Glucose depletion affects the prefrontal cortex (responsible for decision making).
• Stress hormones impair executive function.

This explains why both Sarah and Mike struggled most during their respective "critical periods":

• Morning: First 60 minutes (cortisol awakening response or CAR).
• Evening: Last 90 minutes of work (peak decision fatigue).

How Decision Fatigue Leads to Relapse

Decision fatigue makes it difficult to sustain the mental energy required to maintain new habits. By the end of the day, when your willpower is at its lowest, you're more likely to make choices that align with comfort rather than growth. Understanding this cycle can help in planning your most important habits during times of peak willpower. This framing reference can be applied to meal skipping and cravings for refined Carbohydrates, or any similar 'reward' situation.

Building Resilient Habits: The Three Pillars

1. Energy Management

Managing your energy is crucial for building sustainable habits. Instead of relying solely on willpower, managing energy levels helps ensure that you're equipped to follow through with your intentions.

Morning Ritual Strategy:

• Prepare environment the night before.
• Create a "morning sanctuary" space.
• Implement the two-minute rule—start with just two minutes of the new habit to build momentum.

Evening Wind-Down Strategy:

• Schedule physical reset activities (e.g., stretching, a short walk).
• Create transition rituals that signal the end of work. It might be a cup of tea or exercise.
• Build in recovery periods to replenish mental and physical energy. Small breaks during the day, in between meetings or calls, accommodation exercises if you're always working in front of the screen. Standing and stretching if you don't have a standing desk.

2. Environmental Design

Recent research in behavioral psychology shows that environment shapes about 90% of our automatic behaviors. Here's how to use this:

For Morning Success:

• Designate a morning-only space.
• Remove work items from morning areas.
• Set out tools the night before (place the Green container prominently).

For Evening Resilience:

• Create physical distance from triggers (store alcohol in a less accessible place).
• Establish new wind-down stations (a reading nook).
• Design alternative reward paths (replace evening drinking with herbal tea, a light workout, or a creative activity such as drawing or woodworking).

3. Recovery Protocol

The most crucial element isn't preventing lapses—it's having a robust recovery system. In the event of a relapse;

The 24-Hour Reset:

1. Immediate Action
2. • Reset environment now.
   • Don't wait for tomorrow.
   • Document current state (write down what went wrong - you don't need to show it to anyone).
3. Root Cause Analysis
4. • Identify trigger cascade (e.g., stress, proximity to triggers).
   • Map energy levels (when are you most vulnerable?).
   • Note environmental factors contributing to the lapse.
5. Strategic Restart
6. • Rebuild morning/evening sanctuary.
   • Reestablish primary cues (set reminders).
   • Reinforce support systems (accountability partner).

The Path Forward: Creating Your Resilience Plan

Step 1: Map Your Critical Periods

• Identify energy peaks and valleys.
• Note decision-heavy times.
• Mark high-risk situations (after stressful meetings).

Step 2: Design Your Environment

• Create supportive spaces for your new habits.
• Remove friction from desired actions (schedule a post-work walk at a specific time, or leave a reminder note on your desk).
• Add friction to unwanted behaviors (keep unhealthy snacks out of sight or better don't buy them). Don't go shopping if you're hungry either!

Step 3: Build Your Support System

• Share your commitment with a trusted friend or group.
• Set up accountability measures (weekly check-ins).
• Plan celebration milestones to reward progress and keep motivation high. For example, slowly upgrade your kitchen tools if you like to cook.

Conclusion: The Reality of Lasting Change

Change isn't about perfection—it's about resilience. Both Sarah and Mike eventually succeed not by eliminating lapses, but by building systems that made recovery automatic and growth inevitable.

Sarah's Greens routine succeeds by a decluttered morning space and a simple evening setup routine. Mike transforms his evening stress response with a combination of exercise, environmental changes, and supportive social connections. When we talk about readiness to change we ask our clients how ready they think their family and friends are to support them through their change.

Sarah and Mike's stories teach us that lasting change comes not from willpower alone, but from understanding and working with our brain's natural tendencies. Whether you're building a morning health ritual or breaking an evening stress pattern, success lies in aligning your goals with your neural architecture.

Remember: Every lapse is data, not failure. Use that data to build a stronger system, and let each restart bring you closer to lasting change.

Personal Reflections: Embracing Imperfection in the Change Process

It's important to acknowledge that setbacks are a natural part of growth. Reflecting on your own journey can provide valuable insights:

• What triggers tend to derail your progress? Identifying these helps in designing strategies to address them.
• How do you react to lapses? Cultivating self-compassion can prevent a small lapse from snowballing into a full relapse.
• Who supports your journey? Building a network of people who encourage your growth makes a significant difference.

The key is to keep moving forward—every small step brings you closer to your desired future. Resilient habits are forged through the interplay of persistence, self-awareness, and the systems you create to support lasting change.

You can do it!